Law & Courts

High Court Grants Bail to Anantnag PhD Scholar in Harwan FIR Following Settlement with Complainant

NEWS AGENCY KASHMIR NEWS TRUST #KNT

 

Srinagar, Nov 20, KNT: The High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh has granted bail to a 28-year-old PhD scholar from Anantnag in a case registered at Police Station Harwan, Srinagar, after taking note of a settlement reached between the accused and the complainant, who filed an affidavit stating that she had no objection to his release.

Justice Mohd Yousuf Wani allowed the successive bail petition filed by Owais Manzoor Mir, a resident of Pethbugh, Dialgam, Anantnag, who was lodged in Central Jail Srinagar on judicial remand. The order was pronounced on November 20.

The case arises from FIR No. 25/2026 registered at Police Station Harwan under Sections 69, 316(2), 318(2), 319(2) and 125(a) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). The allegations include sexual intercourse on the false promise of marriage, cheating and related offences. The allegations remain subject to adjudication before the trial court.

According to the bail petition, Mir is a full-time PhD research scholar in the Department of Management Studies at the Islamic University of Science and Technology (IUST), Awantipora, where he has been enrolled since 2022. His counsel argued that he had no previous criminal antecedents and that the relationship between the parties had continued for more than 18 months.

The accused’s counsel also questioned the allegations of sexual exploitation and financial fraud, arguing that the material collected during the investigation did not substantiate the charges. The defence further submitted that continued detention violated the accused’s right to personal liberty, particularly after the filing of the charge sheet.

The State opposed the bail plea, maintaining that the allegations were serious and that material evidence, including forensic and electronic evidence, had been collected during the investigation. The prosecution argued that further investigation was continuing and expressed apprehension that the accused could influence witnesses or interfere with the evidence if released.

A significant development before the High Court was an affidavit filed by the complainant on October 23, 2026, stating that the parties had amicably settled their disputes through a settlement deed executed in Srinagar. She stated that she no longer had any grievance against the accused and had no objection to his release on bail.

Her counsel, Advocate Shahzada Saleem, also appeared before the Court on October 29 and submitted that the parties had settled the dispute and had approached the trial court seeking permission to compound the offences.

The Court observed that none of the offences alleged against the accused attracted the statutory bar under Section 480(1)(i) of the BNSS, which applies to offences punishable with death or imprisonment for life. It also took note of the complainant’s sworn statement and the settlement between the parties while considering the bail application.

Referring to established principles governing bail, the Court reiterated that deprivation of liberty before conviction should not be punitive and that the seriousness of allegations must be considered alongside the nature of evidence, the possibility of the accused fleeing justice and the risk of interference with the trial.

The Court also referred to judgments of the Supreme Court, including Sanjay Chandra v. Central Bureau of Investigation and Dataram Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh, while examining the balance between individual liberty and the interests of justice.

Mir’s bail application was filed through Advocate Tasaduk Hussain Reshi. The State was represented by Assistant Counsel Nadiya Abdullah, appearing on behalf of Senior Additional Advocate General Mohsin S. Qadiri, while Advocate Shahzada Saleem represented the complainant.

The High Court directed the accused to furnish personal and surety bonds of Rs 2 lakh each, subject to the specified arrangements, to the satisfaction of the trial court and the Superintendent of Central Jail Srinagar.

The bail has been made subject to several conditions. The accused must attend the trial, cooperate with any further investigation, refrain from contacting or confronting the complainant, and must not threaten or influence witnesses. He has also been restrained from leaving Jammu and Kashmir without prior permission of the trial court and directed to surrender his passport if it has not already been retained by the investigating agency.

The Court clarified that the trial court would be competent to proceed against the accused in case of violation of any bail condition. [KNT]

© Kashmir News Trust (KNT). Unauthorized use without attribution is prohibited.

Kashmir News Trust #KNT

Kashmir News Trust (KNT) is a Srinagar-based independent news agency dedicated to delivering timely, accurate, and in-depth coverage from Jammu and Kashmir. Popularly known as KNT, the agency provides a wide range of news, including politics, governance, conflict, environment, culture, and human interest stories. With a strong emphasis on credibility and ground reporting, KNT has emerged as a trusted source of information for readers across the region and beyond. Its reports are widely carried by local and national media outlets, making it a vital link in the flow of news from Kashmir to the wider world.

Related Articles

Back to top button